That’s one key takeaway from a review of environmental management and the use of science during the 2012-2016 drought commissioned by the Delta Science Program and published in the June 2020 issue of San Francisco Estuary and Watershed Science. “There are lots of mysteries about how to manage water to benefit species, agriculture, upstream and downstream users. I think science is going to be the best solution,” says lead author John Durand of UC Davis’ Center for Watershed Science. Durand and his team based their review on available reports and data, as well as discussions with agency staff, stakeholders and researchers. They focused on water management actions during the drought through the lens of four priorities identified by water managers: public health and safety, saltwater intrusion control, preservation of cold water in Shasta Reservoir, and protections for endangered species. “We’re really in sort of a brave new world of droughts,” says Durand, noting that water managers face new challenges as climate change creates more weather extremes. Durand believes that broad, ecosystem-level experiments that include predictions about, and monitoring the effects of, water releases from reservoirs, can provide needed guidance to water managers. He says his team’s research revealed a surprising—and disturbing—lack of data transparency and organization, in spite of recent legislative mandates. “Certainly with the Interagency Ecological Program there’s been a huge push for data transparency, but there are still gaps in other areas,” he says. “The inability to get data about water management decisions in particular generates a lot of controversy.” Furthermore, he says, agencies generate “really important, invaluable reports that appear and disappear with wild abandon across the Internet. So as far as I can tell, there is no real way to archive for posterity the sorts of reports that are generated before, during and after a major event like the drought, which makes it really hard to learn from history.”

Pearls in the ocean of information that our reporters didn’t want you to miss
Image courtesy of NOAA
 

Better scientific preparation could help Delta water and environmental managers respond to droughts more effectively.

That’s one key takeaway from a review of environmental management and the use of science during the 2012-2016 drought commissioned by the Delta Science Program and published in the June 2020 issue of San Francisco Estuary and Watershed Science. “There are lots of mysteries about how to manage water to benefit species, agriculture, upstream and downstream users. I think science is going to be the best solution,” says lead author John Durand of UC Davis’ Center for Watershed Science. Durand and his team based their review on available reports and data, as well as discussions with agency staff, stakeholders and researchers. They focused on water management actions during the drought through the lens of four priorities identified by water managers: public health and safety, saltwater intrusion control, preservation of cold water in Shasta Reservoir, and protections for endangered species. “We're really in sort of a brave new world of droughts,” says Durand, noting that water managers face new challenges as climate change creates more weather extremes. Durand believes that broad, ecosystem-level experiments that include predictions about, and monitoring the effects of, water releases from reservoirs, can provide needed guidance to water managers. He says his team’s research revealed a surprising—and disturbing—lack of data transparency and organization, in spite of recent legislative mandates. “Certainly with the Interagency Ecological Program there's been a huge push for data transparency, but there are still gaps in other areas,” he says. "The inability to get data about water management decisions in particular generates a lot of controversy.” Furthermore, he says, agencies generate “really important, invaluable reports that appear and disappear with wild abandon across the Internet. So as far as I can tell, there is no real way to archive for posterity the sorts of reports that are generated before, during and after a major event like the drought, which makes it really hard to learn from history.”

About the author

Cariad Hayes Thronson covers legal and political issues for Estuary News. She has served on the staffs of several national publications, including The American Lawyer. She is a long-time contributor to Estuary News, and some years ago served as its assistant editor. She lives in San Mateo with her husband and two children.

Related Posts

Climate change is heating, salinizing, and expanding the San Francisco Estuary, a review of nearly 200 scientific studies concludes.

Sea level rise, changing snow and rainfall patterns, and warmer waters are some of the changes already observed in the Estuary and expected to continue through the rest of the century as greenhouse gas concentrations rise. Changes to water are at the heart of the documented and further expected impacts;...

Groundwater pumped from subsided islands back into Delta channels through 200 or more active outfalls can be laden with excess nitrogen transported from island soils, report the authors of a new study.

The Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta contains more than 50 peat islands. Most have subsided—some as much as three meters — as a result of drainage for farming, and must maintain artificial water tables below the land surface via managed pumping. According to researchers from the University of California at Santa Cruz...

A large pulse of water sent through the Yolo Bypass in summer 2016 boosted phytoplankton biomass and food web conditions in Cache Slough and the lower Sacramento River, a new report confirms.

 “Our goal was to improve estuarine habitat by increasing net flows through the Cache Slough Complex to enhance downstream transport of lower trophic-level resources, an important driver for fish such as the endangered Delta Smelt,” write the authors—including esteemed (and recently retired) California Department of Water Resources lead scientist Ted...